By Team Clarion

PRAYAGRAJ — The retirement of Allahabad High Court judge Shekhar Kumar Yadav has once again brought attention to a long-standing controversy over his abusive remarks about Muslims, with questions being raised over accountability and delay in action.

Justice Yadav retired on Wednesday after completing his tenure. However, the issue surrounding his objectionable statements during a public event continues to remain unresolved.

The controversy dates back to December 8, 2024, when Justice Yadav attended a programme organised by the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) in Prayagraj. The event, held at the High Court library building, included discussions on the Waqf Board law, religious conversion and the Uniform Civil Code.

During his speech, Justice Yadav spoke in favour of the Uniform Civil Code, stating that it would bring equality and uniformity in laws across different religions. He said, “Uniform Civil Code is based on equality and justice and aims to remove separate legal systems based on religion.”

However, several of his remarks about Muslims during the same speech triggered widespread criticism. He made comments on practices such as multiple marriages, triple talaq and halala, and used words that were seen as offensive by many in the Muslim community. Critics said such statements from a sitting judge raised serious concerns about impartiality.

The matter gained national attention after the Supreme Court took note of the issue. Following this, an impeachment motion was also introduced against him in Parliament. Despite this, the process remained pending for over a year.

Legal observers and members of civil society have expressed concern over the delay. A senior advocate, requesting anonymity, said, “When a judge makes remarks targeting a community, it affects public trust in the justice system. Delay in action only deepens that concern.”

Members of the Muslim community also voiced disappointment. One community representative said, “We expect fairness from judges. Statements like these hurt sentiments and create fear among minorities.”

This story was originally published in clarionindia.net. Read the full story here.